Dear Seniors, please explain the following. I am not able to understand. Section 11A of the Maternity Act safeguards the intent of Section 48 of the Factories Act, 1948, which requires factories with more than 30 female workers to have a creche. Therefore, even if a factory has less than 50 employees but has at least 30 females, such factory will be under the obligation to have a creche under the Factories Act, 1948. Further, if Section 11A of the Maternity Act had been framed to be applicable on establishments with 50 or more female employees, then, Section 48 of the Factories Act, 1948, would have lost its effect as factories having more than 30 women workers but less than 50 women workers would have done away with the compliance of having a creche.
From India, Hyderabad
2From India, Hyderabad
If the factory comes under ESIC act, maternity act is not applicable over there. So follow the rule prescribed under factory act.
From India, undefined
From India, undefined
Dear Abhiram
Maternity benefit Act, Factories Act and ESIC Act are all seprate and exclusive acts. The ESCI act only absolves employers responsibilities in terms of maternity benefits prescribed under Maternity benefit Act.
Your confusion is valid as through the last amendment the MB act has made compulsory provision of creche where there are 50 or more Employee- watch here the word EMPLOYEE is used and not FEMALE EMPLOYEE- Im not sure any clarification has been made or not with regards to this blunder.
Factory act specifically mentions that creche to be provided wherever there are 30 or more Female workers are engaged (this includes contract workers also).
For both the act the competent authority is Factory Inspector. May follow Factories Act provisions till further clarification by your state either through rule or notification has been made.
Shailesh Parikh
99 98 97 10 65
Vadodara
From India, Mumbai
Maternity benefit Act, Factories Act and ESIC Act are all seprate and exclusive acts. The ESCI act only absolves employers responsibilities in terms of maternity benefits prescribed under Maternity benefit Act.
Your confusion is valid as through the last amendment the MB act has made compulsory provision of creche where there are 50 or more Employee- watch here the word EMPLOYEE is used and not FEMALE EMPLOYEE- Im not sure any clarification has been made or not with regards to this blunder.
Factory act specifically mentions that creche to be provided wherever there are 30 or more Female workers are engaged (this includes contract workers also).
For both the act the competent authority is Factory Inspector. May follow Factories Act provisions till further clarification by your state either through rule or notification has been made.
Shailesh Parikh
99 98 97 10 65
Vadodara
From India, Mumbai
Dear colleagues,
In a factory (as defined under Factories Act 1948) a creche is required if there are 30 female workers are engaged by occupier. Not necessary under this provision here that all 30 should be married or one is requiring facility of Creche, but law demands a creche is must. Similarly, by reading MB Act notified and applicable effective 1st April 2017, if there are 50 employees (male and female together included) in any establishment then creche facility is must. Here ,this provision is specially introduced for establishment registered under Shops and Establishments Act 1948. So ,we have to be clear wrt both enactments which are differently and separately made applicable-One for Factories and second for workplaces under ambit of Shops and Establishments but clearly unconcerned .So, if you are factory manager, if you have requirement of creche because more than 30 females are engaged then you should have a creche and in your head /Corporate office which is registered under Shops and Establishments Act, suppose you have 32 female employees working with only 15 male employees (Total strength is 47) then Creche facility is not to be provided at Corporate Office because total employees strength is less than 50 even though female strength is more. Take a different case where in another situation , even 1 female employee is working in any office registered under Shops and Establishment Act, with 52 male employees (Total 53) then creche has to be provided as total strength is more than 50 EMPLOYEES. These situations are embarrassing and an example of unmindful live acts on the part of Government.Objectivity is some thing, enactments are causing direct impact on women employment. Who will engage 1 female among 52 and maintain princely creche for ???
Work places registered under Shops and Establishments Act are not inspected under Factories Act by Factory Inspectors. Such establishments are inspected by Labour Enforcement Officers .
From reading of both above, it is evidently clear that Govt. has taken hasty steps which would cause drastic reduction in women employment , making available pool of talent un-utilized .
Thanks and regards,
From India, New Delhi
In a factory (as defined under Factories Act 1948) a creche is required if there are 30 female workers are engaged by occupier. Not necessary under this provision here that all 30 should be married or one is requiring facility of Creche, but law demands a creche is must. Similarly, by reading MB Act notified and applicable effective 1st April 2017, if there are 50 employees (male and female together included) in any establishment then creche facility is must. Here ,this provision is specially introduced for establishment registered under Shops and Establishments Act 1948. So ,we have to be clear wrt both enactments which are differently and separately made applicable-One for Factories and second for workplaces under ambit of Shops and Establishments but clearly unconcerned .So, if you are factory manager, if you have requirement of creche because more than 30 females are engaged then you should have a creche and in your head /Corporate office which is registered under Shops and Establishments Act, suppose you have 32 female employees working with only 15 male employees (Total strength is 47) then Creche facility is not to be provided at Corporate Office because total employees strength is less than 50 even though female strength is more. Take a different case where in another situation , even 1 female employee is working in any office registered under Shops and Establishment Act, with 52 male employees (Total 53) then creche has to be provided as total strength is more than 50 EMPLOYEES. These situations are embarrassing and an example of unmindful live acts on the part of Government.Objectivity is some thing, enactments are causing direct impact on women employment. Who will engage 1 female among 52 and maintain princely creche for ???
Work places registered under Shops and Establishments Act are not inspected under Factories Act by Factory Inspectors. Such establishments are inspected by Labour Enforcement Officers .
From reading of both above, it is evidently clear that Govt. has taken hasty steps which would cause drastic reduction in women employment , making available pool of talent un-utilized .
Thanks and regards,
From India, New Delhi
I suppose we need to understand the intention of the amendment of MB Act. In today's context where we have both the parents working or an eventuality of single parent the need for creche is not limited to female parent.
Hence, the act is amended to 50 employees and not restricted it to any gender.
From India, Hyderabad
Hence, the act is amended to 50 employees and not restricted it to any gender.
From India, Hyderabad
Find answers from people who have previously dealt with business and work issues similar to yours - Please Register and Log In to CiteHR and post your query.
Creche under Maternity Benefit Act.pdf
MATERNITY BENEFIT ACT 2009.doc